Old Homestead Steakhouse

Located in the heart of New York City's vibrant Chelsea neighborhood, Old Homestead Steakhouse stands as a timeless beacon for steak lovers and American cuisine aficionados alike. This historic steakhouse masterfully blends classic charm with a warm, inviting atmosphere, offering guests a culinary experience that’s both nostalgic and satisfying.

The menu is a carnivore’s dream, featuring standout dishes that promise to ignite your taste buds. Start your meal with the Colossal Crab Cake served with a light, tangy classic remoulade that bursts with fresh crab flavor, or savor the Old Homestead Caesar salad, where crisp romaine is topped with rich Parmesan croutons and perfectly balanced classic dressing. Meat lovers won’t want to miss the iconic Prime Barrel Cut Filet Mignon, celebrated for its buttery tenderness and exquisite seasoning—a true testament to the kitchen’s craft. For a hearty indulgence, the Manhattan Lobster Mac & Cheese offers a luscious blend of creamy cheese and tender lobster morsels that sing with comforting decadence.

The steakhouse’s famed BURGER BASH selection is a robust lineup of gourmet burgers that satisfy any appetite. From the juicy 20oz Kobe Burger accompanied by crispy French fries and a smoky chipotle ketchup, to the 10oz Peppered Slab Bacon Burger layered with house-cured black and white peppercorns and aged cheddar, each bite delivers bold, satisfying flavors. The 10oz Filet Mignon Burger crowned with mountain-high seasoned onion rings offers an elevated burger experience that evokes true steakhouse indulgence.

Side dishes here are more than just accompaniments; they’re vital components of a perfect meal. Treat yourself to the rich, velvety Truffle Mac & Cheese, the crispy and flavorful Buttermilk Onion Rings, or the garlicky, creamy Garlic Mashed Potatoes. The kitchen’s attention to detail ensures every element on your plate complements the exquisite quality of their steaks and burgers.

Customer reviews echo the restaurant’s stellar reputation. David Martin praised the “bacon-wrapped filet” and “20oz burger,” noting the food was a delightful departure from traditional holiday fare. Robb Greenhill raved about the “phenomenal” crab cake and perfectly seasoned, medium-rare sirloin. Joanna Ioanna fondly recalled the place’s historic charm and the uniquely pureed French onion soup—a perfect appetizer to the juicy, wood smoke-tinged steaks that impressed her so much she wished for more room. Similarly, K Howell highlighted the “divine” Gotham rib steak paired with excellent service and a lively ambiance, making the Old Homestead experience truly memorable.

Whether you’re a steak connoisseur seeking perfectly cooked, succulent cuts or someone looking to indulge in classic American dishes with a refined touch, Old Homestead Steakhouse delivers consistently on flavor, quality, and atmosphere. For those who appreciate the art of steak and crave a rich, timeless dining experience, this New York gem is not to be missed.

Contact Information:
56 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States
Phone: +1 212-242-9040